The Builder's Verdict

Best accounting and MTD software for UK trades (2026)

BV-G-008Best-ofDesk assessed

By Jake WalkerCommercial links disclosed below

The shortlist verdict

For a contractor who needs to file CIS300 directly, Sage Accounting Standard and Plus are the documented options (Sage's support says Start only supports CIS as a subcontractor, so a contractor needs to upgrade); Xero offers it on Ignite and above for an extra £5 a month, while QuickBooks confirms it on Simple Start, Essentials and Plus. FreeAgent records CIS and produces the figures but does not submit CIS300 itself. Sole traders focused on MTD for Income Tax should start with FreeAgent, Xero or QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus; a non-VAT-registered sole trader without CIS can also look at Sage's free Sole Trader plan. This is a desk assessment, not hands-on testing; the comparison was initially checked 21 August 2026, Xero plan details were rechecked 29 October 2026 and Sage's MTD for Income Tax position was checked against HMRC's software finder on 30 October 2026.

Desk assessed: We checked current UK pricing against official vendor sources, read the official documentation and terms, and weighed public user evidence. Some records also include clearly bounded trial spot-checks, but not enough first-hand workflow evidence to earn the Trial account used level.

What that doesn't mean: That we've run the product on live customer work over time. Long-term reliability, mobile field use and support quality stay unverified unless the record says otherwise.

What earned a place on this list

  • Available in the UK with a current, verifiable price
  • MTD capability described precisely rather than as one blanket badge
  • CIS subcontractor recording and contractor CIS300 filing kept separate
  • Limitations and unverified points stated instead of inferred

MTD and CIS at a glance

Desk-assessed from vendor documentation checked 21 August 2026, with Xero rechecked 29 October 2026 and Sage's MTD for Income Tax entry checked against HMRC's software finder on 30 October 2026.

Swipe the table sideways to see every product.

MTD and CIS features in the checked supplier documentation
ProductMTD for VATMTD for Income TaxSubcontractor CISDirect CIS300 filing
Sage AccountingConfirmedListed by HMRC (as “Accounting from Sage”)ConfirmedStandard and Plus; Start is subcontractor-only
FreeAgentConfirmedConfirmed on Sole TradersConfirmedNo, figures prepared for external filing
XeroConfirmedConfirmed on current tiersConfirmedConfirmed on Ignite and above, £5/month add-on
QuickBooks OnlineConfirmed from Simple StartConfirmed on Sole Trader PlusConfirmed on named tiersConfirmed on Simple Start, Essentials and Plus

The shortlist

Sage Accounting

Best choice for contractor CIS300 filing (Standard and Plus)

Sage's support documentation says Standard and Plus can run CIS as a subcontractor, a contractor or both and submit CIS returns to HMRC online, using your own HMRC credentials. Start is different: Sage's Start support article says you can only be a CIS subcontractor there and need to upgrade to set up as a contractor. That explains why Sage's plan comparison table ticks CIS on Start while its plan cards list contractor CIS from Standard. For contractor CIS300 filing, budget for Standard. Payroll is bundled too. HMRC's software finder lists "Accounting from Sage" for MTD for Income Tax quarterly updates and the tax return; Sage's own accounting product page focuses its MTD wording on VAT.

From £20 per month ex VAT (introductory £2/mo for 6 months when checked, 1 user) · 30-day free trial, or the introductory discount above instead of a trial · checked 21 Aug 2026

FreeAgent

Best starting point for sole-trader MTD for Income Tax

The Sole Traders plan is explicitly built around quarterly MTD for Income Tax updates and a final declaration. It supports CIS records for contractors and subcontractors, but it does not submit the monthly CIS300 return directly.

From £19 per month ex VAT (introductory £9.50/mo for 6 months when checked) · 30-day free trial · checked 21 Aug 2026

Xero

Best balanced option with direct CIS filing available

Xero's main price table shows Ignite, Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate; its separate Simple page also has a Buy link for non-VAT-registered businesses. Xero labels all five MTD for Income Tax ready and lists subcontractor CIS calculations. Contractor CIS return submission costs an extra £5/month on Ignite and above; Simple's page does not list that add-on. Check the exact plan before buying. The 1 September 2026 price rise is now in effect; see the dated price note for current tier prices.

From £18 per month ex VAT (introductory £1.80/mo for the first 6 months when checked) · One month free, or the introductory discount above instead of a trial · checked 11 Sept 2026

QuickBooks Online

Best range of tiers, but check the CIS detail

Sole Trader Plus is explicitly MTD for Income Tax ready and the wider range scales to 25 users. Direct CIS300 filing is confirmed on Simple Start, Essentials and Plus, not on every tier; payroll is a separate paid product.

From £10 per month ex VAT (introductory £1/mo for 6 months when checked, 1 user) · 30-day free trial, or the introductory discount above instead of a trial · checked 21 Aug 2026

The decision depends on which side of CIS you are on

A subcontractor who only needs deductions recorded does not need the same workflow as a contractor filing a monthly CIS300 return. All four products document CIS capability, but that single label hides the important difference: FreeAgent does not submit CIS300 directly, Sage does, Xero does on Ignite and above with a paid CIS add-on, and QuickBooks confirms direct filing only on named tiers.

That distinction is more useful than a generic feature count. Decide first whether you file CIS300 as a contractor, record deductions as a subcontractor, or do neither; then compare the MTD and company-type fit.

MTD for VAT is not MTD for Income Tax

Do not treat an 'MTD ready' badge as one blanket promise. MTD for VAT and MTD for Income Tax are separate schemes. Xero states MTD for Income Tax readiness across its current plans; FreeAgent has a dedicated Sole Traders plan; and QuickBooks explicitly marks Sole Trader Plus as ready. Sage's accounting product page describes VAT calculation and submission; for MTD for Income Tax, HMRC's own software finder (checked 30 October 2026) lists "Accounting from Sage" as paid software that sends quarterly updates and submits the tax return for sole trader and UK property income.

Sage's free Sole Trader plan is a different product

Sage also sells Sage Sole Trader, separate from the Sage Accounting tiers in this shortlist. Its free plan is single-user and aimed at non-VAT-registered sole traders: Sage lists one connected bank account, five sales invoices a month, manual receipt entry and the SA103S Self Assessment summary. HMRC's software finder lists "Sage Sole Trader & Landlord Free" as a free product for quarterly updates and the tax return.

The catch for trades is CIS. Sage lists CIS calculation on the paid Sole Trader plan (£7 a month ex VAT after a 90%-off first six months when checked), not on the free one, and neither plan is for VAT-registered businesses. A CIS subcontractor should compare the paid plan against FreeAgent, Xero and QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus; a contractor filing CIS300 needs the Sage Accounting tiers above. We have not tested either Sage Sole Trader plan.

How to use this shortlist

Shortlist by business type and tax workflow before price. Then confirm the exact tier contains the capability you need, check the standard price after the introductory offer, and use the trial with fictional data before moving live records. Payroll is bundled on relevant Xero, FreeAgent and Sage plans in different ways; QuickBooks sells payroll separately, so compare the complete setup rather than the headline subscription alone.

Questions people actually ask

Which accounting software files CIS300 directly to HMRC?

From the four products checked: Sage documents contractor CIS return submission on its Accounting Standard and Plus tiers, while its Start tier supports CIS only as a subcontractor; Xero lists contractor CIS returns as an optional add-on on its current Ignite, Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate plans; and QuickBooks confirms filing on Simple Start, Essentials and Plus. FreeAgent prepares the figures but does not submit CIS300 directly. Confirm the add-on price and your exact tier before buying.

Is MTD for VAT the same as MTD for Income Tax?

No. They are separate schemes and a generic 'MTD ready' statement can hide that distinction. This shortlist records the two separately and leaves a capability unverified when the checked source only describes VAT.

Stay current

The Trade Briefing, every fortnight.

Evidence-checked software and supplier updates, useful UK pricing data, and one practical action. About five minutes to read.

Double opt-in. We'll email you to confirm before anything is sent.

Evidence & sources

  1. Xero plans, MTD for Income Tax status, VAT and £5/month optional contractor CIS return submission on Ignite and above

    Xero (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  2. Xero Simple plan remains available via a separate buy page, includes MTD for Income Tax and subcontractor CIS reports, but does not list the contractor CIS return add-on

    Xero (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  3. FreeAgent plan pricing and MTD for Income Tax features

    FreeAgent (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  4. FreeAgent contractor CIS workflow and CIS300 filing limit

    FreeAgent Support · checked · vendor/commercial source

  5. Sage Accounting tiers, VAT, payroll and CIS features

    Sage (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  6. Sage Accounting plan comparison table: "Manage and submit CIS" ticked on Start, Standard and Plus (CIS row only; the table does not distinguish subcontractor from contractor)

    Sage (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  7. Sage Sole Trader page, VAT-registered plan cards: "Manage and submit CIS" listed as a Standard addition ("Everything from Start and")

    Sage (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  8. Sage support, Set up CIS for your business (Sage Accounting Start; created 9 Aug 2023, last modified 22 Mar 2024): Start supports CIS only as a subcontractor; upgrade needed to set up as a CIS contractor

    Sage Support (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  9. Sage support, Sage Accounting features (created 5 Jul 2021, last modified 5 Oct 2021): Standard and Plus can record CIS as subcontractor, contractor or both, verify subcontractors and submit HMRC CIS returns online

    Sage Support (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  10. HMRC's MTD for Income Tax software finder (sole trader or landlord route) lists "Accounting from Sage" (paid) and "Sage Sole Trader & Landlord Free" (free) for quarterly updates and the tax return, sole trader and UK property income

    HM Revenue & Customs · checked

  11. Sage Sole Trader plans: Free (single user, non-VAT-registered, 1 bank account, 5 sales invoices a month, SA103S summary, no CIS listed) and Sole Trader (£7/month ex VAT after 90% off for 6 months, adds CIS calculation, receipt capture, multiple bank accounts, unlimited invoices)

    Sage (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  12. QuickBooks UK tiers, MTD and pricing

    QuickBooks (vendor) · checked · vendor/commercial source

  13. QuickBooks CIS300 filing tier applicability ("File a CIS return in QuickBooks" help article, tagged Simple Start, Essentials and Plus)

    QuickBooks Support · checked · vendor/commercial source

Prices and terms change. If a source above no longer matches what we've written, tell us via the corrections page and we'll fix it.